A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system

Twitter went mad last week because somebody had transferred almost $150m in a single Bitcoin transaction. This tweet was typical:

There was much comment about how expensive or difficult this would have been in the regular banking system – and this could well be true.  But it also highlighted another point: in my expecience, almost nobody actually understands how payment systems work.  That is: if you “wire” funds to a supplier or “make a payment” to a friend, how does the money get from your account to theirs? 

In this article, I hope to change this situation by giving a very simple, but hopefully not oversimplified, survey of the landscape.

First, let’s establish some common ground

Perhaps the most important thing we need to realise about bank deposits is that they are liabilities. When you pay money into a bank, you don’t really have a deposit. There isn’t a pot of money sitting somewhere with your name on it. Instead, you have lent that money to the bank. They owe it to you.  It becomes one of their liabilities. That’s why we say our accounts are in credit: we have extended credit to the bank.  Similarly, if you are overdrawn and owe money to the bank, that becomes your liability and their asset.  To understand what is going on when money moves around, it’s important to realise that every account balance can be seen in these two ways.

Paying somebody with an account at the same bank

Let’s start with the easy example. Imagine you’re Alice and you bank with, say, Barclays. You owe £10 to a friend, Bob, who also uses Barclays. Paying Bob is easy: you tell the bank what you want to do, they debit the funds from your account and credit £10 to your friend’s account.  It’s all done electronically on Barclays’ core banking system and it’s all rather simple: no money enters or leaves the bank; it’s just an update to their accounting system.  They owe you £10 less and owe Bob £10 more. It all balances out and  it’s all done inside the bank: we can say that the transaction is “settled” on the books of your bank.  We can represent this graphically below: the only parties involved are you, Bob and Barclays.  (The same analysis, of course, works if you’re a Euro customer of Deutsche Bank or a Dollar customer of Citi, etc)

Single Bank Settlement

But what happens if you need to pay somebody at a different bank?

This is where it get more interesting.  Imagine you need to pay Charlie, who banks with HSBC. Now we have a problem: it’s easy for Barclays to reduce your balance by £10 but how do they persuade HSBC to increase Charlie’s balance by £10?  Why would HSBC be interested in agreeing to owe Charlie more money than they did before?  They’re not a charity! The answer, of course, is that if we want HSBC to owe Charlie a little more, they need to owe somebody else a little less.

Who should this “somebody else” be?  It can’t be Alice: Alice doesn’t have a relationship with HSBC, remember.  By a process of elimination, the only other party around is Barclays. And here is the first “a ha” moment…  what if HSBC held a bank account with Barclays and Barclays held a bank account with HSBC? They could hold balances with each other and adjust them to make everything work out…

Here’s what you could do:

  • Barclays could reduce Alice’s balance by £10
  • Barclays could then add £10 to the account HSBC holds with Barclays
  • Barclays could then send a message to HSBC telling them that they had increased their balance by £10 and would like them, in turn, to increase Charlie’s balance by £10
  • HSBC would receive the message and, safe in the knowledge they had an extra £10 on deposit with Barclays, could increase Charlie’s balance.

It all balances out for Alice and Charlie… Alice has £10 less and Charlie has £10 more.

And it all balances out for Barclays and HSBC.  Previously, Barclays owed £10 to Alice, now it owes £10 to HSBC. Previously, HSBC was flat, now it owes £10 to Charlie and is owed £10 by Barclays.

This model of payment processing (and its more complicated forms) is known as correspondent banking. Graphically, it might look like the diagram below.  This builds on the previous diagram and adds the second commercial bank and highlights that the existence of a correspondent banking arrangement allows them to facilitate payments between their respective customers.

Correspondent Banking

This works pretty well, but it has some problems:

  • Most obviously, it only works if the two banks have a direct relationship with each other. If they don’t, you either can’t make the payment or need to route it through a third (or fourth!) bank until you can complete a path from A to B. This clearly drives up cost and complexity. (Some commentators restrict the use of the term “correspondent banking” to this scenario or scenarios that involve difference currencies but I think it helpful to use the term even for the simpler case)
  • More worryingly, it is also risky. Look at the situation from HSBC’s perspective.  As a result of this payment, their exposure to Barclays has just increased.  In our example, it is only by £10.  But imagine it was £150m and the correspondent wasn’t Barclays but was a smaller, perhaps riskier outfit: HSBC would have a big problem on its hands if that bank went bust.  One way round this is to alter the model slightly: rather than Barclays crediting HSBC’s account, Barclays could ask HSBC to debit the account it maintains for Barclays. That way, large inter-bank balances might not build up. However, there are other issues with that approach and, either way, the interconnectedness inherent in this model is a very real problem.

We’ll work through some of these issues in the following sections.

[Note: this isn’t *actually* what happens today because the systems below are used instead but I think it’s helpful to set up the story this way so we can build up an intuition for what’s going on]

Hang on… why are you making this so complicated? Can’t you just say “SWIFT” and be done with it?

It is common when discussing payment systems to have somebody wave their hands, shout “SWIFT” and believe they’ve settled the debate.  To me, this just highlights that they probably don’t know what they’re talking about 🙂

The SWIFT network exists to allow banks securely to exchange electronic messages with each other. One of the message types supported by the SWIFT network is MT103. The MT103 message enables one bank to instruct another bank to credit the account of one of their customers, debiting the account held by the sending institution with the receiving bank to balance everything out.  You could imagine an MT103 being used to implement the scenario I discussed in the previous section.

So, the effect of a SWIFT MT103 is to “send” money between the two banks but it’s critically important to realise what is going on under the covers: the SWIFT message is merely the instruction: the movement of funds is done by debiting and crediting several accounts at each institution and relies on banks maintaining accounts with each other (either directly or through intermediary banks).  Simply waving one’s hands and shouting “SWIFT” serves to mask this complexity and so impedes understanding.

OK… I get it. But what about ACH and EURO1 and Faster Payments and BACS and CHAPS and FedWire and Target2 and and and????

Slow down…..  Let’s recap first.

We’ve shown that transferring money between two account holders at the same bank is trivial.

We’ve also shown how you can send money between account holders of different banks through a really clever trick: arrange for the banks to hold accounts with each other.

We’ve also discussed how electronic messaging networks like SWIFT can be used to manage the flow of information between banks to make sure these transfers occur quickly, reliably and at modest cost.

But we still have further to go… because there are some big problems: counterparty risk, liquidity and cost.

The two we’ll tackle first are liquidity and cost

We need to address the liquidity and cost problem

First, we need to acknowledge that SWIFT is not cheap. If Barclays had to send a SWIFT message to HSBC every time you wanted to pay £10 to Charlie, you would soon notice some hefty charges on your statement.  But, worse, there’s a much bigger problem: liquidity.

Think about how much money Barclays would need to have tied up at all its correspondent banks every day if the system I outlined above were used in practice. They would need to maintain sizeable balances at all the other banks just in case one of their customers wanted to send money to a recipient at HSBC or Lloyds or Co-op or wherever.  This is cash that could be invested or lent or otherwise put to work.

But there’s a really nice insight we can make:  on balance, it’s probably just as likely that a Barclays customer will be sending money to an HSBC customer as it is that an HSBC customer will be sending money to a Barclays customer on any given day.

So what if we kept track of all the various payments during the day and only settled the balance?

If you adopted this approach, each bank could get away with holding a whole lot less cash on deposit at all its correspondents and they could put their money to work more effectively, driving down their costs and (hopefully) passing on some of it to you.  This thought process motivated the creation of deferred net settlement systems.  In the UK, BACS is such a system and equivalents exist all over the world.  In these systems, messages are not exchanged over SWIFT.  Instead, messages (or files) are sent to a central “clearing” system (such as BACS), which keeps track of all the payments, and then, on some schedule, calculates the net amount owed by each bank to each other.  They then settle amongst themselves (perhaps by transferring money to/from the accounts they hold with each other) or by using the RTGS system described below.

This dramatically cuts down on cost and liquidity demands and adds an extra box to our picture:

Deferred Net Settlement

It’s worth noting that we can also describe the credit card schemes and even PayPal as Deferred Net Settlement systems: they are all characterised by a process of internal aggregation of transactions, with only the net amounts being settled between the major banks.

But this approach also introduces a potentially worse problem: you have lost settlement finality. You might issue your payment instruction in the morning but the receiving bank doesn’t receive the (net) funds until later.  The receiving bank therefore has to wait until they receive the (net) settlement, just in case the sending bank goes bust in the interim: it would be imprudent to release funds to the receiving customer before then.  This introduces a delay.

The alternative would be to take the risk but reverse the transaction in the event of a problem – but then the settlement couldn’t in any way  be considered “final” and so the recipient couldn’t rely on the funds until later in any case.

Can we achieve both Settlement Finality and Zero Counterparty Risk?

This is where the final piece of the jigsaw fits in.    None of the approaches we’ve outlined so far are really acceptable for situations when you need to be absolutely sure the payment will be made quickly and can’t be reversed, even if the sending bank subsequently goes bust.  You really, really need this assurance, for example, if you’re going to build a securities settlement system: nobody is going to release $150m of bonds or shares if there’s a chance the $150m won’t settle or could be reversed!

What is needed is a system like the first one we outlined (Alice pays Bob at the same bank) – because it’s really quick – but which works when more than one bank is involved.  The multilateral bank-bank system outlined above sort-of works but gets really tricky when the amounts involved get big and when there’s the possibility that one or other of them could go bust.

If only the banks could all hold accounts with a bank that cannot itself go bust… some sort of bank that sat in the middle of the system.  We could give it a name.  We could call it a central bank!

And this thought process motivates the idea of a Real-Time Gross Settlement system.

If the major banks in a country all hold accounts with the central bank then they can move money between themselves simply by instructing the central bank to debit one account and credit the other.  And that’s what CHAPS, FedWire and Target 2 exist to do, for the Pound, Dollar and Euro, respectively. They are  systems that allow real-time movements of funds between accounts held by banks at their respective central bank.

  • Real Time – happens instantly.
  • Gross – no netting (otherwise it couldn’t be instant)
  • Settlement – with finality; no reversals

This completes our picture:


I thought this article had something to do with Bitcoin?

Well done for getting this far.  Now we have a question: can we place Bitcoin on this model?

My take is that the Bitcoin network most closely resembles a Real-Time Gross Settlement system. There is no netting, there are (clearly) no correspondent banking relationships and we have settlement, gross, with finality.

But the interesting thing about today’s “traditional” financial landscape is that most retail transactions are not performed over the RTGS. For example, person-to-person electronic payments in the UK go over the Faster Payments system, which settles net several times per day, not instantly.   Why is this?  I would argue it is primarily because FPS is (almost) free, whereas CHAPS payments cost about £25.  Most consumers probably would use an RTGS if it were just as convenient and just as cheap.

So the unanswered question in my mind is: will the Bitcoin payment network end up resembling a traditional RTGS, only handling high-value transfers?  Or will advances in the core network (block size limits, micropayment channels, etc) occur quickly enough to keep up with increasing transaction volumes in order to allow it to remain an affordable system both for large- and low-value payments?

My take is that the jury is still out: I am convinced that Bitcoin will change the world but I’m altogether less convinced that we’ll end up in a world where every Bitcoin transaction is “cleared” over the Blockchain.

[Updated several times on 25 November 2013 to correct minor errors and to add the link to my Finextra video at the end]

216 thoughts on “A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system

  1. I think for day to day transactions (buying groceries and so forth), players like Coinbase will start alleviating a lot of the pressure on the blockchain. In a similar fashion, they will act as a bank, only changing the numbers in between accounts.

  2. Hi Simon,

    I’m inclined to agree. I think there are two major forces driving us towards this sort of outcome. 1) the “average” user is likely to trust a reassuring brand more than themselves to manage their wallet, driving a move to a bank-like “safekeeping” business model and 2) the blockchain may not be the best vehicle for micro-payments. Combine those two observations and you end up with your prediction: there is a gap in the market for off-blockchain ‘aggregators’ of smaller transactions.

    But I also know that many of the core developers, with infinitely more knowledge of the system disagree with this analysis!


  3. Great post. Bitcoin protocol works well between untsted parties that know what are they up to, non reverse, etc. In this case, no need for a Central Bank. Most average users, as you say, still need trusted relations, so there will always be a trusted layer above Bitcoin for anyone in need for it, giving some space to the current retail banking model. Banks do have a place in the Bitcoin scenario, same as today, but the difference is that you could still operate without them if you wish. Banks will be just another option.

  4. Excellent article Richard. I found myself asking a few questions as I read it, most of which you answered.
    “CHAPS payments cost about £25”. Do they really, or is that just the price? Do they charge that much because they want to make money, or because they want to dissuade us from using that method or because they really do cost?
    Are SWIFT messages signed? In other words if they contain non repudiation then surely they are a transfer of value rather than just the veil that you describe, however your focus is on whether the sender will go bust rather than deny sending it so it’s not relevant here.
    Surely this whole thing is just an model to allow us to understand things. There’s still no actual value moving around, so it’s not much more true than just saying that you’re moving money. But of course it is a much more thorough model that allows you to do more things.
    Surely bitcoin is still just the movement of liabilities. It still doesn’t have a real value until the sender gives up their sheep and the recipient receives a goat (or whatever else it is that makes the money have value to them). – I know you answered this by comparing to a gross settlement system rather than to real value.

  5. Pingback: A Simple Explanation of How Money Moves Around The Banking System | Enjoying The Moment
  6. Pingback: Linux Mint Czech - Bitcoin, a ako sa pohybujú peniaze v bankovom systéme at Linux Mint CZ&SK
  7. Great article, it’s always easier to understand with small examples.
    BUT I really didn’t like the graphs you did, mostly because the arrows go both ways. In the first example for instance, the arrow going from Alice to the bank shouldn’t go both ways. But it’s just my opinion.

  8. @Jaumenuez I agree; I think we’ll see a federated model of the sort you describe – but, also as you say, with the option of going “direct” for those who know how to and want to

    @benjamin – thanks. Good point re the diagrams; you’re right. The arrows are confusing. Sorry!

    @sean – thanks for the link

    @kassner – I left FX as an “exercise for the reader” but you’re right… the principles can be extended. e.g. imagine Barclays held a *dollar* account with Citi. That would give Barclays customers a way of making Dollar payments – and so on. Indeed, this cross-border example is what most people think of when you say “correspondent banking”. If you follow this line of reasoning, the counterparty risk problems becomes even greater and you end up with a need for an “RTGS for FX”, if you like. This motivated the creation of the CLS Bank.

  9. @Sam:

    * CHAPS – fair point. They’re “charged” at about £25. They probably cost a lot less.
    * SWIFT messages – not sure if they’re cryptographically signed but the key thing that SWIFT offers that the internet does not is security at the end points and within the network. i.e. if you receive a SWIFT message purporting to be from Barclays, you can be pretty sure it *is* from Barclays!
    * Bitcoin is interesting – because it doesn’t really fit the “liability” model. My holding of Bitcoins are nobody else’s liability. This makes them quite unlike any major currency today – and far more like gold or a commodity.

  10. Thank you very much for an interesting and educational blog post. I found it interesting because it sheds *some* light on a recent banking problem that left me quite stumped.

    I recently attempted a $5000 bill payment from a debit account to a credit card, and due to a policy restriction, the bank holding the debit account canceled the payment. When I called their customer service department, they informed me of the restriction and told me I could try again that day. I tried again, and the payment went through fine. However, I was quite surprised when I checked my credit card account a few days later and discovered that both payments had been processed on their side leaving me with a $5000 credit balance! The debit account was only debited once. I called the credit card company and everything they could see on their end showed two successful and proper payments. I called the debit account company and spent over an hour on the phone with various people there, but none of them could find any trace of the duplicate payment. All they could see was the canceled bill pay and the successful one, but they couldn’t find any evidence of the extra $5000 that I received.

    Of course, I’d love to just take the money and run, but I feel it is likely that one day, they will audit or balance their accounts and discover it, then come asking me for the money.

    If you are interested, I’d love to get some insight into how this happened and maybe some tips on who I could ask to speak with that might be able to do something about it since it appears to be out of the league of the customer service department. I’m sorry for being a bit vague with the details, but I believe that this problem might actually be a reproducible flaw in their system, and I don’t want to set them up for fraudsters to take advantage of it.

  11. @Daniel Einspanjer

    Rinse, repeat. 🙂

    Serioulsy, would be interested to find out what the result of this “error” ends up being.

  12. Good explanation of the different transfer systems. Could you please add snippets of the following equivalents for India into the explanations at appropriate places?
    1. Net settlement system done in batches several times a day – NEFT (National Electronic Fund Transfer) Monday through Saturday.
    2. RTGS (it’s the same definition as above), done through the central bank – Reserve Bank of India. There is a minimum transfer amount of Rs. 200, 000 (called Rs. 2 Lakhs locally) for using RTGS, while there is no minimum for NEFT.
    3. IMPS – Immediate Payment Service – instant, multiple channels (like SMS, web, etc.) and available 24 x 7 (unlike NEFT and RTGS that are not available on holidays and Sundays).

    The fee for using these services varies across banks, amounts and account types.

  13. Pingback: How Your Money Moves In The Banking System | Terraformed
  14. @jorge — Yeah, I’m not about to try and see if it is a vulnerable flaw in their system. It is easily provable that the first time was an accident and I went to great lengths to document my notification to them. If I go trying it again “just to see if it works” I’d quite likely be facing criminal charges from them regardless of whether it is their own stupid fault for not listening to me. :/

  15. Excellent tutorial, there. 🙂

    From the viewpoint of teaching the basics to people with no professional finance background, though, there’re a couple of more questions I’d like to hear an answer for:

    1. What’s the difference between commercial bank account and retail bank account? I’ve never heard of such terms.
    2. If these international RTGS services do exist, what is it that’s retarding their use? If I make an account transfer from my bank to some account abroad, they’re always saying it’s going to take a long time. Are even the services of central banks so expensive that the real time transfer is only a service to those who are ready to pay more?

  16. @indiasurfer – thanks for the comments. It’s great to get insight into the equivalent systems elsewhere.

    Could you say a little more about how IMPS works? Who runs it? The central bank? A third party? Do funds ultimately arrive at a bank account? It sounds a little like a more advanced version of the UK’s Faster Payments service – in which funds are shown in recipients accounts immediately but the banks only settle amongst themselves every so often – but it would be great to hear more.



  17. Great article. Would it be possible for you to take some time to write a similar piece on securities trading and settlement. That would be awesome!

  18. I have a question: If we already have a central bank system for moving money around, why do we still have the deferred net settlement systems like ACH around?

  19. visite http://www.placasparceria.com.br

    Desenvolvemos Brindes Corporativos e Pessoais, Placas de Homenagem para diversas ocasiões, Placas Comemorativas, Medalhas, Trofeus, Gravação a Laser, Corte a Laser, Corte acrilico, Gravação Laser acrilico, Troféus em aço, Troféus Esportivos, Pins, Projetos Especiais, Campanhas Publicitárias, Crachás, placas anti-corrosão, placas de Inauguração, Chaveiros, Brindes Empresarias, no mais alto padrão de acabamento, Empresa localizada em São Paulo.

  20. Pingback: Somewhere else, part 94 | Freakonometrics
  21. Pingback: A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system / goccedisaggezza
  22. Thanks for the pretty thorough explanation 🙂

    What I’m wondering: If the system is instant, why does a SEPA transfer still take a whole day to arrive?

  23. Pingback: Coder Read #20131127: XOWA, an offline application for Wikipedia | Coders Grid
  24. This is worth reading a number of times. Always good to have a better understanding of something we use everyday, but don’t ever get told how it all actually works. As crucial to our lives as plumbing or electricity. Have reblogged it on http://leifdavidsen.wordpress.com/

  25. Pingback: How Money moves around the Banking System | AccidentalCapitalist
  26. Nice read. Though I understand that there is a lot more to this than I care to know.
    I have been reading the book “Lords of Finance” – the story of the great depression.

  27. Pingback: Link blog: filtering, england, censorship, transfer | Name and Nature
  28. Pingback: Links & reads for 2013 Week 48 | Martin's Weekly Curations
  29. Pingback: From the Archives: 11/25/2013 Edition « whatsjohnreading
  30. Pingback: Linkspam, 12/6/13 Edition — Radish Reviews
  31. Pingback: Links: Mandela and Great Leaders; WTO deal in Bali; How Money Works
  32. Stellar writing Richard. What are your favorite books on this topic and banking/transactional processing in general?

  33. Pingback: Ban Bitcoin! (demands VISA) | gert.is
  34. @marinatin thanks for the feedback. I really like Alec Nacamuli’s book on payment systems (disclosure: he’s a colleague) and the European Central Bank did a great book on how securities processing systems work. From a business perspective, Celent often produce good papers on the custody business.

  35. Pingback: Reading List 21st Nov, 2013 | Capsule
  36. Pingback: A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system | The Renewable ChallengeThe Renewable Challenge
  37. Pingback: A Simple Explanation of How Shares Move Around the Securities Settlement System | Richard Gendal Brown
  38. Pingback: Bitcoin isn’t Money—It’s the Internet of Money | The Ümlaut
  39. Pingback: Links von 15.11.2013 bis 09.01.2014 | Mythopoeia 2.0
  41. Pingback: Bitcoin, a ako sa pohybujú peniaze v bankovom systéme - Linux Mint CZ&SK
  42. Pingback: payment21® blog » What does Bitcoin mean in terms of clearing and settlement for the global banking industry?
  43. Pingback: Fun economic reading | MuddyHorse Farm and Tech
  44. Pingback: Übersicht: Wie bewegt sich Geld in unserem Finanzsystem um die Welt? | Vomitorium
  45. Pingback: Compilado de enlaces | programacion@droope
  46. Pingback: Ripple is hard to understand, but it’s worth making the effort: there’s a deep insight at its core | Richard Gendal Brown
  47. Hi my name is David, I want to show you how you can generate thousands dollars is automatically.Automatic Website Builder is the best website builder software on the market for creating, publishing, managing and monetizing new and existing websites with the help of Google AdSense and other pay-per-click and Clickbank, Amazon affiliate programs. Equipped with innovative features that are not available anywhere else, our automatic website generator enables you to build top-quality websites for virtually unlimited revenue. VISIT THIS LINK http://bit.ly/1jv2rUH

  48. David- Great article. Wish you had a bitcoin tip address posted so I could show a little support! Another idea is that hopefully services like ChangeTip will integrate with WordPress soon.

  49. Hi Richard – Really nice explanation of what is/can become a complex topic.
    You may also consider adding something on how some deferred net settlement schemes/solutions have solved for the Settlement Finality problem – eg the use of authorisation systems and payment guarantees in use with the card schemes and similar with FPS.

  50. Pingback: Bitcoin and Bankers: Reflections on a panel discussion | Richard Gendal Brown
  51. I understand so far – RTGS system as explained by your really applies to all the banks in one country having an account with the central bank. I however need to send money from country a to country b – it begs the question do central banks have their own central bank to central bank clearing system.

  52. @Mendi – good question and yes. It’s called CLS Bank. Probably worth a post in its own right – but plenty of info on wikipedia, etc., about it and why it was created( namely: the failure of Herstatt Bank in 1974, which made it clear to everybody quite how much risk is hidden inside the correspondent banking system)

  53. Why can’t International transfers simply go through the VISA network. Since international remittance is so expensive. And VISA is only 2-3%?

  54. @sida – I guess we have to distinguish between international remittance and regular international payments. My guess is that recipients of remittances (typically) don’t have access to payment cards (hence remittance firms’ agent networks) and that regular international payments probably cost a bit less than an international visa transaction. Just a hunch though – it’s a good question

  55. That helped a lot, great article! There are just a few things that I don’t understand though:

    1) What happens when a customer of Bank A wants to send funds to a customer of Bank B when the two banks have different currencies and Bank A does not have enough funds at Bank B to complete the transfer? Lets also assume that Bank A also does not have enough funds at a path of correspondent banks or central banks to get to Bank B and that more money needs to be sent from A to B than from B to A.

    I guess the gist is that Bank A’s accounts are underfunded at correspondent banks.

    What must Bank A then do to complete the transfer? Must it send cash on a ship?

    2) Also, how is it that my local bank has physical foreign currency notes for withdrawal?


  56. Hi! Do banks use their own bank branches as correspondent banks? For example, can BNP Paribas in France us BNP Paribas in New York as its correspondent bank account?

  57. @Charly – 1) I guess you’re talking about the problem of liquidity management, etc. One option is for the short bank to buy what it needs on the FX market (e.g. if they’re a British bank, find a counterparty somewhere who is willing to sell the target currency for pounds). Another option is to delay the payment… i.e. defer paying out until enough funds to cover it have arrived, etc

    2) Not sure why this would be a problem… think of the bank as a retailer… they have some foreign currency in stock (in their inventory), which they have presumably already paid for. And they recoup the cost when they sell it to you.

  58. @MZ – Good point. Banks certainly do use their overseas entities to make payments abroad. So perhaps one way to interpret my piece is to think of smaller regional banks that don’t have their own international network.

  59. Pingback: The “Unbundling of Trust”: how to identify good cryptocurrency opportunities? | Richard Gendal Brown
  60. So sidechains become interesting when you consider bitcoins future is arguably as the RTGS for cross border transactions without countries that don’t have reliable central banks or correspondent banks.

    I’m curious if stellar could be a bitcoin sidechain. So you get a layered model.

    P2P payments
    Custodians to manage that as a liability on case of lost or stolen devices
    Stellar and other sidechains facilitate inter p2p service transactions and custodial relationships
    The Custodians then use bitcoin as an RTGS where there is no central bank.

  61. Somebody pointed out to me in private conversation the other day that you don’t need a sidechain to integrate with stellar/ripple – a gateway is all you need!

  62. It should be technically trivial to scale up the transaction volume to “PayPal-level” (I’m actually working on code to test that right now); scaling up to “Visa-level” will be trickier, but processing financial transactions is much easier than all the other things computers can do quickly (video, speech recognition, 3D rendering…) nowdays.

    I’ll be pushing to keep Bitcoin transactions cheap and accessible to everybody, not just people with millions of dollars to move around.

  63. @gavin – thanks for the comment. It’s a fair point… we do have to look at large numbers in context and with the perspective of time. e.g. imagine all 2bn internet users wanted to do one on-blockchain transaction per year. You’d need to be able to process about 64tps (I think. I really hope I didn’t screw up the maths). So, allowing for EVERYBODY to do one a month would need about 1000tps (ignoring for now that peaks would be way in excess). Assume 250bytes/tx and you’re looking at about 21Gb per day…. about 100Tb per year. A petabyte for a decade of transactions. 10^15 or so, give or take an order of magnitude.

    Now some people will need to do far more transactions but not everybody is going to use a system like this so perhaps these are reasonable numbers to play with.

    10^15 *sounds* like a lot — and maybe the real requirement is higher…. but we already know we’ll have to deal with at least 10^21 bytes routinely in the broader IT industry a few years from now. And the idea of storing this on thousands of nodes is obviously troublesome. But it’s not *obviously* insane (well, maybe a little bit insane).

  64. Hello Webmaster do you want unlimited content for your site?

    100% unique and human readable. Type in google:
    Nyschash’s Rewriter

  65. Pingback: Distributed Ledgers and Disintermediation of Trust | Crypto 2.0
  66. Pingback: A Simple Model for Smart Contracts | Richard Gendal Brown
  67. Pingback: A Central Bank “cryptocurrency”? An interesting idea, but maybe not for the reason we think | Richard Gendal Brown
  68. Hi Richard,

    Thank you so much for such an informative and clear explanation on the topic. I would like to ask a question, hope you could kindly enlighten me. If the Central bank system can eliminate all the key risks involved in the “transfer” money among the banks, why would banks still using defer net settlement systems? What are some of the types of transactions that works better with defer settlement and why?

    Thank you so much for your time and attention!


  69. Hi Richard,

    Great article. As a corporate treasurer what would consider the biggest risks I need to be aware of in making international payments and other then ensuring accuracy of the payments details and mitigating against internal fraud what can you do about them.


  70. ‘there is a gap in the market for off-blockchain ‘aggregators’ of smaller transactions’ – the real problem with bitcoin is the incredible waste of energy. just SUCH a waste. awful. ie joules.

  71. Pingback: How Money Moves Around The Banking System | Bitcoin Codex
  72. Pingback: A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system (2013) | Reddit Spy
  73. Pingback: Bookmarks for April 25th | Chris's Digital Detritus
  74. I enjoy, lead to I discovered exactly what I was having a look for.
    You have ended my four day lengthy hunt! God Bless you
    man. Have a nice day. Bye

  75. Thanks for the crystal clear explanation. My next query – for international exchanges – where there is a net amount of money owing from one country’s citizens to another country’s citizens, is there ever a real transfer of …. something? Would this something be what I’ve heard to be “reserves in such-and-such a currency” held by a central bank?

    Fascinating subject…. Frank

  76. frank – great question. I don’t know for sure but my thinking would be something like this. Let’s imagine lots of citizens of country A want to move their money out, perhaps to country B. What would that look like? The end-result would be that citizens in country A are owed less of currency A by the banks of country A and more of currency B by the banks of country B, right? So why would the banks of country B agree to owe them more?

    For me, I guess there are really only three options:

    1) The banks of country B are willing to increase their holdings of country A’s currency (either in the form of reserves at country A’s central bank or by being owed more of country A’s money by the banks of country A). They’d presumably only be willing to do this at an unfavourable exchange rate in times of stress? The result would be the sending currency’s value dropped, exascerbating the problem I imagine?

    2) The banks (or central bank?) of country A hand over some of their holdings of country *B* currency, to the extent they have enough and are willing to. I think this is your “reserves transfer” scenario, right? Again, this can only work for so long: eventually the bank(s) will run out of foreign reserves. Perhaps this is similar to what happened to the UK on Black Wednesday? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Wednesday). i.e. you can think of the central bank in this scenario as using their foreign holdings to purchase its own currency from those wanting to sell it, perhaps with the intent of propping up the price. In this scenario, those selling Currency A then store the country B currency they’ve acquired from the country A central bank at a bank in country B

    3) The banks of country B buy/accept *assets* in country A. Imagine you own a factory in country A. Rather than selling it then transferring the money out, you simply sell it *for* foreign currency. Alternatively, you could imagine this being intermediated by the banks. i.e. when you ask your bank to buy Currency B for you, they “pay” for it by handing over assets they own in country A.

    This really isn’t my area of expertise, however, and working things out from first principles can often lead people astray… so please only treat this as a suggestion for how it works..!

  77. Hi Richard,I really want to thank you for the clear explanation about the swift, and the example given 🙂

  78. Thanks for your suggestions Richard – in response to my question on the same day – May 17 2015.

    Without me having more formal knowledge of international banking and finance, all three of your suggested mechanisms (transferring foreign reserves) would probably work in different circumstances. I checked out the Black Wednesday reference, and in principle, running out of foreign reserves may have been the reason that defending the UK Pound may have failed – though it spoke of the “speed” at which trades were completed, at which point I realised I needed to know more to understand this.

    I am continuously amazed at how seemingly ‘simple’ concepts, such as representing value of goods / services by a currency, or IOU, can become so incredibly involved: And useful to those who understand it.

    Thanks you again for your explanations and insights.

  79. Hi Richard, I’m struggling to understand the swift message MT202, please assist.

  80. HelloRichard Gendal Brown,please can you tell me about Draft ,because one company want to do project true my company but he want to send 50Million Draft to my bank,also i don’t know anything about draft payment can you please help me out maybe is good to or not so i can know next step to take thanks

  81. HelloRichard Gendal Brown,please can you tell me about Draft ,because one company want to do project true my company but he want to send 50Million Draft to my bank,also i don’t know anything about draft payment can you please help me out maybe is good to or not so i can know next step to take thanks

  82. hi can anyone on here please help. my husband who works abroad is paid using SWIFT and some payments are lost and do not
    reach the receiving bank inspite of instructions on SWIFT always being the same. an intermediary bank is used as payment is
    in USD and is being converted to uk pounds. The remitting bank is Barclys and intermediary is also Barclays. can someone please help.

  83. Pingback: A Simple Explanation of Balance Sheets (Don’t run away… it’s interesting, really!) | Richard Gendal Brown
  84. Thank you for the fruitful information. I am from Myanmar and I got a presidential scholarship from my government. I got CAS from one of the universities in UK and today, I just transferred all the school fees to the university bank account which exists in Barclays Bank PLC in UK. Banking system in my country is still in the progress, so they don’t have a direct connection with banks from UK. The officials from the bank said that my money would go to Singapore first and then to UK. They said the money can be surely transferred to Singapore but they are not sure whether Barclays bank will accept my money. They also warned me that my money can be transferred back to my country or even BLOCKED for the worst. It concerns me a lot and I will sit for Visa interview within a few days. In which conditions my money will be transferred back to me or blocked? It is not black money and I don’t do any illegal tradings. I am just a simple student. Could somebody explain me? Thanks.

  85. @WMET – Sorry to hear about the uncertainty (and congratulations on the scholarship and CAS). Short answer: I don’t know, sorry. Payments are often blocked if they are to/from people/accounts that are known to be suspicious. That doesn’t seem to be the case here, right? Have you spoken to the university? Perhaps they can speak to their bank to inform them the payment is coming and that it is expected? Sorry I can’t offer any more help than that. Best regards and good wishes for your studies.

  86. Thank you so much. I will inform my school as you suggested. I hope it will help me a lot. Have a nice day. 🙂

  87. please i am looking for a provider of a swift mt103 one confirmation and ready to discount 5% of $500m to EURO500m.

  88. please i am looking for a provider of a swift mt103
    one way confirmation and ready to discount 5% of $
    500m to EURO500m.

    Bank Name:
    Agricultural Bank Of China, Chang Chun Huirong Sub-Branch.

    Bank Address:
    No. 926, Renmin Street, Chang Chun, Jilin Province, China

    Account Name
    Huang Bo Hai Petroleum Chemical Industry Group Co., Limited

    Account No.


    Telephone No:

    Fax No:

    FOR SUPPLY OF 40,000,000,000,000MT metric tonnes OF LPFO
    AND READY TO RECEIVE SBLC OF $40,000,000,000.00.
    ….the above stated format is a five years contract.we are looking for a Bank that can send RWA to the above company’s Bank in china and sespond with SBLC which will last for five and let us know how much percentage discount of the amount involved they will take .
    please any capable hand can contact me through johnmicheal.jm77@gmail.com
    this is a supply of LPFO .

  90. Savvy discussion ! I am thankful for the analysis – Does someone know where I might be able to get access to a blank 2012 GSA SF-424 copy to fill out ?

  91. This is not the platform for transactions, I dont think but where people who have had problems or need clarity with banking systems can share their experiences and probably get a way forward.

  92. Pingback: A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system | Zealous Thinking
  93. Thanks for a great post Richard. Could you please expand to treat FX transactions?

    Best regards,

  94. I think this is a great article that I have been looking for, as people often too easy to spell SWIFT and think they know all. One question though — how do banks “deposit” money to a Central Bank? In the RTGS model, wouldn’t a bank need to keep a lot of deposit in Central Bank for settlement?

  95. Hi Gendal, another question about MT103 — in this message it only says what are the ordering and receiving customer’s account numbers are. But it does not say what the bank’s reciprocal account numbers are. Are the reciprocal account numbers part of SWIFT setup agreement (something pre-agreed between banks) so they are not required in MT103? Thanks.

  96. Pingback: Media hypes Banks vs Fintechs, but real battle could be big banks vs small banks | Daily Fintech
  97. Pingback: Media hypes Banks vs Fintechs, but real battle could be big banks vs small banks | Bank Innovation
  98. This is the right blog for everyone who wishes to find
    out about this topic. You understand a whole lot its almost hard to
    argue with you (not that I really will need
    to…HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject
    which has been discussed for ages. Wonderful stuff, just wonderful!

  99. Pingback: How Money Moves - CURATIO Magazine
  100. Pingback: Bitcoin Protects Users Against Financial Social Engineering Attacks
  101. Very interesting article. MT103 is also aptly named “Single Customer **credit** transfer”, not **money** transfer..

  102. Very good article, thanks.

    I actually came across the article whilst trying to establish if the following:

    1) Are there any existing practices for effecting payments where the Beneficiary has requested to be paid in a currency in which they (Beneficiary) & their Bank does NOT hold any (Vostro) account in?

    2) More specifically also, if the Paying Bank sends an MT103 in the currency requested to the Bank which holds an account in that currency with them (Paying Bank) & which (MT103 Receiving Bank) also maintains a different (Vostro) account for the Beneficiary’s Bank[& the paying bank places cover funds in the currency requested in the (Vostro) account of the MT103 Receiving Bank]:

    a) Is there any practice the MT103 Receiving Bank can use to pass on the MT103 (& related cover funds) to the ultimate Beneficiary’s Bank &

    b) More specifically, can the MT103 Receiving Bank (unilaterally) convert the payment into the currency in which they maintain a (Vostro) account for the Beneficiary’s Bank, place the cover funds (in the new currency) into the (Vosto) account of the Beneficiary’s Bank with them (MT103 Receiving Bank) & send an enhanced MT103, either:

    (i) In the original (instructed) currency (& amount), specifying that cover funds are placed (& providing exchange rates used, charges taken, etc, in Field 72, etc) or

    (ii) In the new currency (& amount), specifying that cover funds are placed in the (uninstructed currency) Vostro?

  103. Richard,

    Though I am not from a financial background, your article has helped me in developing an opinion about the banking between banks. A simple example like this really makes it easy to grasp the concept.

    Thank You

  104. great article, I work in bank IT and never really thought about this before. Anyone have any similar articles on how money is created?

  105. Can you please clarify something for me? I understand that, for risk considerations, banks are using central banks’ settlement accounts rather than other banks’ settlement accounts. That being said, why would one need to be using another bank’s settlement account at all? All banks could simply solely use the central bank for that purpose. thanks

  106. Thanks so much for this explanation, Gendal. I’ve spent the entire day trying to learn what actually happens between banks when you “send” money to someone. Almost everything else I’ve found glosses over the technical details, which is incredibly frustrating. Your description here is easy to follow and understand. Cheers for making knowledge and understanding accessible to the masses.

    by: Mr DICKSON

    Would you like to travel out of your country?
    Have you been denied visa several times?
    well that ends today because Mr,Dickson can provide
    you with different platform to any were in the that
    benefits to you for more information contact us at
    Email: (dicksonfasturgentvisa@gmail.com)


  108. can you provide mt 103 .mt110 for my client ,he needs it to draw down from a credit line,if yes pls send your number to me,my no is 2348131025546 and send your procedure also,thank you
    Daniel O.R

  109. This may seem like a inane question, but I am wondering if you can assist. The above explanation of how money is transferred is extremely helpful. In relation to RTGS I fully understand how this can result in settlement finality and importantly zero counter party risk. However, it got me thinking how do banks transfer money into their respective Central bank account electronically. Does the Central Bank have a correspondent relationship with each of the member banks? If it doesn’t, how would they debit/credit their respective accounts to facilitate the transfer. Alternatively, if the Central Bank does hold an account with the member banks, does this not put the Central Bank at counter party risk? As the commercial bank could simply credit the liability account of the Central Bank , and in turn debit their asset holding at the Central Bank when they want to hold cash at the Central Bank. Consequently, the Central Bank would credit the liability account of the commercial bank and debit their asset holding at the Commercial Bank (an obvious counter party risk).

    Am I missing something? Any assistance would be greatly appreciated.

  110. Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice at the same time as you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a blog website? The account aided me a appropriate deal. I have been tiny bit familiar of this your broadcast offered shiny clear concept

  111. Hello everyone. I was heartbroken because quickly ejaculation each time I’m having sex with my partner. This have cause a big problem in many of my relationship, not nice to satisfy a woman, i had so many relationship called off because of my situation, i have used so many product which i found online but none could offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments about this specialist called Dr. Ogala and I decided to email him on: ogalasolutiontemple(at)gmail. com so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal pills and I’m now very strong in bed, and i can make love for more than one hour. My partner now respect me. Thanks to Dr. Ogala. he have save my life and my relationship. I’m so happy.. For those who are have the same situation should feel free to contact DR Ogala on his Email: ogalasolutiontemple(at)gmail. com

  112. Attention: Sir/Ma.
    This is to inform the general public that those who have be scammed or defrauded by some internet loan lending companies or by other methods have been giving the opportunity to recover their lost money by the International Police Africa (Interpol), they have been able to carry out investigations and arrest some of the Loan Lending Companies, please only those who have legit evidence about been defrauded will be attended to and you will be compensated with a certain amount. Please help to share this message so many brothers, sisters and friends have been a victim. Kindly contact International Police Africa (INTERPOL) on email:
    internationalpol.co.za@safrica.com for more information.

  113. The question thats brought me to this article is still not answered. Or if it is, I didn’t understand.

    How do banks actually settle their balances? Do they send trucks with cash, gold, etc… How does that work for foreign currencies?

  114. Pingback: So you Want to Understand Bitcoin… (Part 1) – Governology
  115. Dear Partner/Associate,

    We offer Legitimately Cash & Asset Backed Financial Instruments on Lease and Sale at the best rates and with the most feasible procedures. Instruments offered can be put in all forms of trade and can be monetized or discounted for direct funding. We offer certifiable and verifiable bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capable of taking up time bound transactions.


    Kindly contact for genuine inquiries and I can provide you with the needed information.

    Abdulaziz Mobarak
    Email: am.leasebroker@gmail.com
    Skype: am.leasebroker

    Financial Mandate on Bank Instruments

    Best Regards,
    Abdulaziz Mobarak

    Financial Consultant
    Company Name : AMK Financial Consultant Ltd

  116. Hello admin, do you monetize your blog ? There is easy method to
    earn decent money every day, just search on youtube : How to earn with wordai 4

  117. Hello Dear,

    I have offers such as BG/SBLC ,MT760,MT103,MT103/202, CASH TRANSFER, LC
    via MT700, MT799, MTN’s, Euro Clear, Bank Draft. Am ready to work with you
    depending the offers you are Interested on. I Want Reliable Client not
    time Wasters.We are tested and trusted.For further communication get
    back to me with your full information.

    Joseph Mark
    Skype ID: jmark.14141

  118. Pingback: A gentle introduction to interbank payment systems | Bits on blocks
  119. We are mandate to providers who specialized in BG, SBLC MTN, CD, Non collateral loan, confirmable Bank Draft and other financial assistance from AAA rated bank (Prime Bank). Intermediaries/ Consultants/ Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and are 100% protected. In complete confidence, we will work together for the benefits of all parties involved. Also we have facilities to discount BG and Put you into PPP Trading. We also secure funding, project loans for 3% APR Intermediaries/Consultants/Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and are 100% protected. In complete confidence, we will work together for the benefits of all parties involved. Our terms and procedures are so flexible and workable by RWA clients.

    If Interested kindly contact the details below.

    Name: Abdul Harris Rahman
    Email: mandate.sblcbg@gmail.com
    Skype: mandate.sblcbg

  120. Pingback: A simple explanation of how money moves around the banking system – Site Title
  121. I lost over 64k USD to binary options brokers while trying to invest my Gratuity. I hired a Pro who helped me charge back and recouped all my funds. contact me on katiecor44@gmail.com. I will be willing to share my experience with you.

  122. Greetings to you,

    We are one of the America, Europe, Asia and Africa Private leading Investment Company that offers soft loan.
    Do you need business loan, personal loan, agricultural loan or project funding?
    We have good news for you. We are financially capable to grant you loan once you meet our requirements.
    For more information, please contact me via this email: janetwilliams906@gmail.com or whatsapp number: +1 323 451 1894

    Best Regards,
    Janetloans & WilliamsMerchant.

  123. I’m glad I was able to recover my funds, I would have had to file for bankruptcy, thanks to Geminihacks (dot) (com). I was able to get a hold of these scam brokers and take back my money. I would gladly refer anyone

  124. I have noticed you don’t monetize your page, don’t waste your
    traffic, you can earn extra cash every month because you’ve got high quality content.
    If you want to know how to make extra money, search for: Boorfe’s tips best adsense alternative

  125. To the Klaus Kleinfeld of Alcoa Inc. CBS anchor woman Cindy Hsu recently got involved in dirty coraption business with infamous CBS anchor Otis Livingston to steal money from Alcoa Inc. employees bank accounts. never trust Cindy Hsu and Otis Livingston they need to be put in jail!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  126. I would like to say thank you to Chrysler kings financial investment for all the things they have helped me with. I have a large family, and every time we have had a crisis Chrysler kings Loan finance has helped us out.need for extra money can arise at just about any time. they pride themselves on being able to meet your needs and provide a loan for just about any reason you may need. their process is 100% online, quick and simple.they provide

    Home Loan
    Car Loan
    Real Estate
    Company Project
    Business Loans
    Loan to buy Property
    Company Expansion
    Personal Loan [secure and unsecured]
    Students Loan and so many others.

    I thank God for the help they have provided to me and my family,email them today at {chryslerkings_financialinvest@aol.com
    or call: (409) 794-4376

    Best Regards
    Julia Jeehee chung

  127. Great Post 🙂 I always have thought how many settlement accounts each bank may have to finally reconcile the GL accounts 🙂
    Saying that I have a question or two mostly on international transfers. Being in US we still can use ACH with IAT SEC or can use MT 103 from SWIFT. Again as you well pointed out these all are instructions and how does the physical fund moves?
    Assume a scenario : – I have a a bank account in a US Bank and another bank account in India. I can walk to a branch and can initiate a wire. A MT 103 would be send with the remittance information but not sure how the funds will be settled? As now the banks are trading currencies and who decides how much I get? The fees and charges for wire are extra. If so then how the companies like Xoom or Western Union makes money? Do they deal with swap or forward?

  128. Pretty pictures you got . am really sorry for invading your private space .hopefully i will like for us to build on this new found friendship .I am Paul Ajeti, Am from Belgium, i work with the us army and presently in Yemen for peace keeping.. I’m a christian, A Roman Catholic by birth and I try to stay close to God as much as I can. Tell me about yours? What is your religion? What is your belief? I don’t judge people, hence I am very comfortable with whatever you believe in.

  129. Hello All

    This is Tarsha, I want you to know that I just received my loan of $25,000.00 from Larry Finance, after I was let down by other lenders, i saw a post from Mr. Paul Hector on how they helped him also, i quickly applied, and they Have really put a smile on my face, now I can take good care of my business and others personal needs, you can contact them for your loan because they are simply the best. Any serious Applicant can reach them with this email via larryfinance@yahoo.com or phone number: +1-580-301-8495

    Contact them now for your loan he is a legit loan lender.

    I assure you all that they are good, no cheating and they are the best company i have ever worked with. Their services are swift and legit. Just go and apply yourself and see what i’m talking about.

    Miss Tarsha Crowns

  130. I also got ripped off by the scammers at Paxful. On their website, I can’t even find any real info on who is behind it! They only have first names – looks like they have something to hide. Pity, was hoping for an honest company until I came across liviacoins. I now trade at http://www.liviacoins.com

  131. Project financing program. We offer flexible financing for various projects by following the usual rigorous procedures. This funding program allows a customer to enjoy a low interest rate repayment for as low as 3% per year for a period of 2-30 years. We can approve a financing for up to $500,000,000.00 or more depending on the type of business. Reply us with the information below via our following email: medallionfinance@financier.com

    Amount Needed:
    Monthly/Yearly Income:

    Mr Adams

  132. Dear Sir,

    We have offers such as BG via mt760, mt103 one way,mt103/202 CASH TRANSFER, LC via mt700, mt799, Euro Clear, Certified Bank Draft, Loan,Project Funding, Credit Card Loading, POS TERMINAL offline and online.
    We are ready to work with you depending the offers you are Interested on.We Want Reliable Client not time Wasters. We FINANCE PROJECTS, We also Monetize BG, SBLC. We are tested and trusted.

    You should respond via the electronic email ID (donciagurero7@yahoo.com)


    Mrs.Doncia Gurero

  133. Hello Dear,

    We issue all financial/bank instrument such as: BG/SBLC, BANK DRAFT, MT110, MT103/202, MT799 POF/BLOCK FUND AND ETC.

    The issuing bank moves first with bank to bank email (RWA).

    Email me for procedure and DOA.Bank draft by BG/

    Name: Mark Philip

    Email: markphilip1973@gmail.com

  134. HEY IM SO GLAD !!
    Hello Guys!!!I am Jane i live in Ohio USA I’m 32 Years old , Am so happy I got mine from Esther. My blank ATM card can withdraw $4,000 daily. I got it from Her last week and now I have $12,000 for free. The blank ATM withdraws money from any ATM machines and there is no name on it because it is blank just your PIN will be on it , it is not traceable and now i have money for business,shopping and enough money for me and my family to live on .I am really glad and happy i met Esther because i met Five persons before her and they took my money not knowing that they were scams. But am happy now. Esther sent the card through DHL and i got it in two days. Get your own card from her right now she is not like other scammer pretending to have the Blank ATM card,She is giving it out for free to help people even if it is illegal but it helps a lot and no one ever gets caught or traced . im happy and grateful to Esther because she changed my story all of a sudden . The card works in all countries that is the good news Esther’s email address is estherhadas339@yahoo.com,,

  135. I have lost funds to different binary options brokers and this almost ruined me because i had to hire a lawyer to look into it but nothing worked to get my funds back. I trusted this last broker at IQoptions with 150,000GBP and lost it but i found a Recovery Firm that specializes in funds recovery and they helped me trace the funds and recovered 80% of the investments with the profits. if not for this Firm, my life would be in total ruins, i dont think its right to lose your hard earned money to fake brokers when there is a Recovery Firm available, email firmrecoveryATgmailDOTcom to reach them or via their complaint request form on their site.

  136. I am a mandate to a Finance and Investment Company who is a premier provider of trade finance and project finance instruments as well as discountable bank instruments. We offer Genuine Bank Guarantees, Standby Letter of Credit, Pre Advice / RWA Messages, Documentary Letters of Credit, Bank Draft, Proof of Funds, Performance Bond, Medium Term Notes, and various SWIFT messaging services on lease and sale. We issue these instruments from prime banks, secondary banks, and financial institutions; and transmit SWIFT MT 760, MT 799, MT199, MT999 and other messages on behalf of our clients.

    We offer certifiable and verifiable bank instruments via Swift Transmission from a genuine provider capable of taking up time bound transactions. Kindly contact for genuine inquiries and I can provide you with the needed information.

    LEASING FEE = 4% 2%


    Michael David.
    Contact Mail : riversfinancegroupplc@gmail.com

  137. Hello Dear,

    We issue All types of bank instruments such as BG/SBLC, BANK DRAFT, BCL, MT103 cash backed, MT103/202 cash wire, Bank Letter/Confirmation , MT799 block funds etc.

    Issuing Bank moves first with bank to bank RWA /communications.

    Let me know if you have any need of either of the listed above.

    Email me at: paulharrison809@gmail.com

  138. I lost my job a couple of months ago and I had just a few hundred bucks to my name. I was searching for ways to make money real fast and i bumped into this page from google. At first I was upset but I gave it a try anyways. I ordered for a €10,000 blank ATM card and I got my card delivered here in CA. I was curious so I got up and went quickly to the ATM and to my surprise I was able to withdraw $10500 that day. My card stopped working after a couple of days but I managed to withdraw €20500 in total. Thank you so much, I will order a bigger amount.here is the contact info.to reach the Engineer: rickatmcardoffer@gmail.com and get out of poor hood Thanks very much or what him via 2348108439977

  139. Hello Dear,

    We issue All types of bank instruments such as BG/SBLC, BANK DRAFT, BCL, MT103 cash backed, MT103/202 cash wire, Bank Letter/Confirmation , MT799 block funds etc.

    Issuing Bank moves first with bank to bank RWA /communications.

    Let me know if you have any need of either of the listed above.

    Email me at: paulharrison809@gmail.com


  140. I am a certified Binary options recovery expert, I will guide on steps to take to enable you recover all your money back. Reach out to me on jeremywyatt@consultant,com


    Hello Every One, My Name is David Jimenez
    live in malaysia and life is worth living comfortably for me and my family now and i really have never seen goodness shown to me this much in my life as i am a struggling Dad with three kids and i have been going through a serious problem as my son encountered a terrible accident last week, and the doctors states that he needs to undergo a delicate surgery for him to be able to walk again, and i could not afford the bill for his surgery then i went to the bank for a loan and they turn me down stating that i have no credit card, from there i run to my father and he was not able to help, then when i was browsing through internet answers and i came across a loan lender Dunia Finance
    who provides loans at an affordable interest rate 3% and i have been hearing about so many scams on the internet but at this my desperate situation, i had no choice than to give it an attempt and surprisingly it was all like a dream, i received a loan of $500,000.00 and i payed for my son surgery and thank GOD today he is okay and can walk and is working and the burden is no longer so much on me any more and we can feed well and my family is happy today and i said to my self that i will shout aloud to the world of the wonders of GOD to me through this GOD fearing lender Dunia Finance and i will advise anyone in genuine and serious need of loan to contact this GOD fearing Company at: duniafinance90@gmail.com
    Once again thank you so much Dunia Finance

  142. I am a living testimony of a total life turnaround. I was fortunate to bounce back (recover) from huge financial Investment scam (binary Options and Stox markets ). I met this dude ( after several research and consultations) who specializes in recovering investment funds scam. He helped me recoup my funds from bogus brokers. Today it feels good to share this with you and willing to share more details of my experience. Do not fall for tricks to invest your hard earned funds into any forex, Binary Options or Stox market. It’s all a facade!

  143. I am direct to a Provider of MT103 one-way collateral, MT103 SINGLE CREDIT CASH MANUAL DOWNLOAD. Receiver must be from Top Banks Worldwide. Interested receiver should contact me directly via email:calif.fx1@gmail.com

  144. Pingback: Why should financial services adopt blockchain technology? - WGP Global
  145. We are direct providers of Fresh Cut BG, SBLC and MTN which are specifically for lease, our bank instrument can be engage in PPP Trading, Discounting, signature project (s) such as Aviation, Agriculture, Petroleum, Telecommunication, construction of Dams, Bridges, Real Estate and all kind of projects. We do not have any broker chain in our offer or get involved in chauffer driven offers.

    We deliver with time and precision as sethforth in the agreement. Our terms and Conditions are reasonable, below is our instrument description.

    The procedure is very simple; the instrument will be reserved on euro clear to be verified by your bank, after verification an arrangement will be made for necessary bank documents and stock testing expenses, the cost of the Bank Guarantee will be paid after the delivery of the MT760,

    1. Instrument: Bank Guarantee ) (Appendix A)(BG/SBLC
    2. Total Face Value: Eur 5M MIN and Eur 10B MAX (Ten Billion USD).
    3. Issuing Bank: HSBC Bank London, Credit Suisse and Deutsche Bank Frankfurt.
    4. Age: One Year, One Month
    5. Leasing Price: 6% of Face Value plus 2% commission fees to brokers.
    6. Delivery: Bank to Bank swift.
    7. Payment: MT-103 or MT760
    8. Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    We are ready to close leasing with any interested client in few banking days, if interested do not hesitate to contact me direct.

    Ramadan Rasheed

  146. people say binary options brokers are scam, i can boldly say that’s not true because i have been doing a lot of trading not only that, i have been doing a lot of winnings sometime ago a friend refereed me to One Mr Dylan for assistance with his help and his masterclass strategy I’m able to make $15,000 weekly and a successful withdraw and also recovered all my lost funds, you can contact him for assistance on Dylanryhan1@gmail.com

  147. I recently recovered my invested funds trading binary options from a scam broker. I hired a professional to this effect. I will like to share my experience because it is the right thing. Feel free to reach out pmcq5354@gmail.com

  148. Apparently, binary options is an all or nothing investment. I realized this after losing my Gratuity invested with BinaryTilt. After series of research and consultations with friends and families..I came a across a Charge back Pro who helped me recover all the funds lost. I am excited to share this now that I have my money and also to help other Victims recover their funds too. You can reach out to me on tgermaine173@gmail.com

  149. I recently recovered funds from two scam brokers, Greenfields Capital and OT Capital. they would not allow me withdraw my money and refused to pick any of my calls. I was lucky to have been introduced to a professional who help in getting back all my money. Lesson learnt! Happy to share my experience. beewalker003@gmail.com

  150. I recently just got my money back in my local bank account after being scammed multiple times by people claiming to be able to help. It’s crazy out there ! I’m so happy I was finally able to get my funds back!! Happy to share my experience.
    – Mark Gallagher

  151. About a year ago I invested 385,400USD to Crowd FInance. The broker called me telling me about the gains I stand to get when he trades with my money. Unknowingly to me the Binary options market is just like the gambling industry. You can loose everything you invest in a flash. It was really a sad time for especially because my husband just died at the time and i was trying to maximize the capital i have for investment. Things became unbearable for me and i had no choice than to fight for a recovery. After loosing more money to recovery scam rooms claiming to be able to help, I was finally able to recover with the help of a pro I read about on the deep web. Happy to share my experience. jessicaroberto400@gmail.com

  152. I invested 90% of my retirement payment on binary options with the mindset of getting it multiplied and enjoying a better retirement life. I appreciate Hack Ethics for helping me recover my stolen funds £750,000 from Binary Brokers and Fake Hackers within 48 hours. Contact him or Skype for any desired Hacking Services.It was like a miracle when he helped me recover my £750,000 within 48 hours and now I feel free like a bird. It was sweet and smooth from the start, withdrawals were easy and consistent until it gets to a point I started to be denied withdrawals and that was how I lost all money, I couldn’t get my investment amount back not talk of the bonuses. I contacted several lawyers but it was all waste of time and money, they couldn’t render an inch of help. God so good to my old self and family, I later met with a certified binary options recovery expert that helped me recover my money within 48 hours from the brokers, it was worth it to pay him 20%. You can contact the expert on ”HACKETHICS008@GMAIL.COM” if you have found yourself in same situation as me also he can render any other desired hacking services within 48 hours, I can assure he would be able to help you just as he helped me, you can give him a try if you don’t mind. Binary options brokers shouldn’t get away with this.

  153. I just get a taste of CryptoExMart.com It’s convenient. The price is best and fees are fair enough. It took around 3 hours to actually see cash into my bank account. That’s in my acceptable range.

  154. We are broker firm in London-UK, we have direct Provider of BG/SBLC specifically for Lease and Purchase, The provider is tested and trusted. We have been dealing with the company for the past 6years. Interested Agent/Lessee should contact us for directives.If you have need for corporate loans, international project funding, etc. or if you have a client who requires funding for his project or business we have all available.

    For further details contact us with the below information….

    Email: leasingmandate@gmail.com

  155. I am direct to a Provider of MT103 one-way collateral, MT103 SINGLE CREDIT CASH MANUAL DOWNLOAD. Receiver must be from Top Banks Worldwide. Interested receiver should contact me directly via email: calif.fx1@gmail.com

  156. Hello,

    Are you an employee, self employed or unemployed? You need funding to start or finish a project and Banks have dismissed all your loan applications and wonder how?
    This is an international structure that can help, We are specialized in all types of funding and we work across all continents.

    Contact us today for more information.

    Email: allok.ufgworld@hotmail.com

    Not serious, abstain.

    Universal Financial Group.

  157. Pingback: Seven Simple Rules While Saving Finance - Dual Income No Kids | Dual Income No Kids
  158. Hello, I want to share with you this Honest Loan lending company that lend me a loan to start up a business and pay up my bills with low credit score . i am very happy now. contact Email: Halifaxloan@fastservice. com

  159. We have special cash loaded programmed ATM card for you to meet up with those needs of yours and also start up your own business. Our ATM card can be used to withdraw cash at any ATM or swipe, stores and POS. Our card has daily withdrawal limit depending on the card balance you order.You can make from $2500 to $50,000.00 In USD And EUR,with our Programmed card. Contact us today for your own order at : hennager4040@gmail.com

  160. Hello Everyone, I HJH SITI MAIMUNAH a single mom from Jurong West singapore ,i will like to share this great testimony on how i got my loan from Mrs Linda when we were driven out of our home when i couldn’t pay my bills any more, After been scammed by various companies on line and have been denied a loan by my bank and some other credit union i visited. my children were taken by the foster care, i was all alone in the street. Until a day i shamefully walked into an old school mate who introduced me to MRS Linda At first i told her that i am not ready to take any risk of requesting a loan on line any more, but she assured me that i will received my loan from them. On a second thought, due to my homelessness i took a trial and applied for the loan, luckily for me i received a loan of $20,000.00 from { mrslindarobertloanfirm@gmail.com ). Am happy i took the risk and applied for the loan. my kids have been given back to me and now i own a home and a business of my own.

  161. We are authorized Financial consulting firm that work directly with
    A rated banks eg Lloyds Bank,Barclays Bank,HSBC bank etc

    We provide BG, SBLC, LC, LOAN and lots more for clients all over the world.

    We are equally ready to work with Brokers and financial
    consultants/consulting firms in their respective countries.

    Our procedures are most reasonable and safest as we operate a 100% financial risk free process which entails that the issuing and receiving bank continues the transaction immediately after DOA is countersigned

    We hope to establsih a long term business relationship with you even after this first trial

    email : info.iqfinanceplc@gmail.com
    skype: cpt_young1
    Tel contact: +447031968934

  162. GENUINE BANK GUARANTEE (BG) AND STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT (SBLC) FOR LEASE AT THE LOWEST RATES AVAILABLE.. I am direct to a provider who has recently issued banking instruments for a couple of my clients the provider is 100% check-able you can do your due diligence on them. I personally know the provider. Our instruments are only from triple ‘a’ rated banks and we issue from $1M to $5B . The provider is 100% verifiable. If you are genuinely seeking bank instruments. Contact me and i will furnish you with details. They deal with issuing of instruments such as Bank Guarantee and Standby letters of credit also Letters of credit. I only want serious buyers then i will put you in touch with the provider directly. Bank Guarantee (BG) Standby Letter of Credit (SBLC)

    I will be glad to share with you our working procedures.

    Contact Name: Steve Nguyen
    Email: baseonsteve101@gmail.com
    Skype: financialcapitaltrustplc001
    PH: +13362833097

  163. STOP BEING SCAMMED BY THESE FAKE HACKERS. Hack Ethics is an experienced Private Hacking and Certified Binary Recovery Expert Organization with a spare master key that no one has. Also can help you recover your lost or stolen funds from any Binary Platform and Fake Hackers. Our service takes just within 24-48 hours. Hire a Ethical Hacking Expert who’s professional and real. Specialized in any desired Hacking Services including Romance Scams and so on. Contact – hackethics008@gmail.com.

  164. I know I’m a few years late, but I just wanted to say that this is a brilliant article. It succinctly and clearly explains the basics of how money moves around the banking system. Well done.

  165. Do you need an urgent blank ATM CARD to solve your financial needs, My name is Mrs Dai Renqun, and i just want to tell the world my experience with everyone. I discovered a man online called Richard. he is really good at what he is doing, i inquired about the BLANK ATM CARD. if it works or even Exist, than i gave it a try and asked for the card and agreed to their terms and conditions. three days later i received my card and tried it with the closest ATM machine close to me, to my greatest surprise it worked like magic. i was able to withdraw up to $8500 . This was unbelievable and the happiest day of my life. there is no ATM MACHINES this BLANK ATM CARD CANNOT penetrate into it because it have been programmed with various tools and software. it impossible for the CCTV to detect you i don’t know why i am posting this here, i just felt this might help those of us in need of financial stability. Mr Richard have really change my life. if you want to contact them, HERE is the email address: blankatmcard@aol.com

  166. I received a Master Card just yesterday and it pays me $3000 (3000 THOUSAND USD)at a spot, I tried today again and the same $3000 was paid out, This card will give me 3000 daily for 4 months. If you are in need of urgent money you can get this card as well from Classic Blank ATM Card.email: info.classicblankatmcard00@gmail.com

  167. We are direct provider for BG/SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of (5.0 + 2)% of face value, Issurance by HSBC Bank London , Barclays Bank London , Deutsche Bank, BNP Paribas, & AAA Rated Banks in Europe, Middle East or USA.

    Our BG/SBLC Financing can help you get your project funded, loan financing by providing you with yearly renewable leased bank instruments. We work directly with issuing bank lease providers, this Instrument can be monetized on your behalf for 100% funding: For further details contact us with the below information.

    Contact : Mr.Harrison Martin David
    Email : harrisonfinanceltd@gmail.com
    Skype ID: harrisonfinanceltd

    Intermediaries/Consultants/Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and are 100% protected. In complete confidence, we will work together for the benefits of all parties involved.

    Harrison Martin David

  168. ” I heard about aseiamicrofanance company (Loan Service) in January
    2018, when I was in financial need to expand my restaurant business.
    With the help of their swift financial service, I got my loan and moved
    into a bigger business location. I now make an average of USD 40 daily
    as profit from my restaurant business and find ease in supporting my
    family you can contact them (aseiamicrofanance@gmail.com).”

  169. Dear, Partner/Associate.

    We offer Legitimately Cash & Asset Backed Financial Instruments on Lease and Sale at the best rates and with the most feasible procedures. Instruments offered can be put in all forms of trade and can be monetized or discounted for direct funding.

    Description of Instrument:
    1.Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG)/SBLC
    3.Issuing Bank: HSBC London or AA rated Bank in Western Europe or USA.
    4.Term: One Year, One Month
    5.Leasing Price: 3% of Face Value plus 0.5% Lessor agent [Closed] & X% Lessee agent (open)
    6.Delivery: SWIFT TO SWIFT
    7.Payment: WIRE TRANSFER
    8.Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    Kindly contact for genuine inquiries and I can provide you with the needed information.
    Mr Lube Bujaroski Australian
    Email: lbfunding.bujaros@gmail.com
    Skype ID: lbfunding.bujaros

  170. I am Direct Bank & Provider Mandate of Certifiable and verifiable, bank, instruments in form, BG,SBLC.MT103,one-way collateral, Receiver must be from Top Banks, worldwide, interested, receiver should contact me directly via Email :sarahleasing1@gmail.com

  171. I am direct to a Provider of MT103 one-way collateral, MT103 SINGLE CREDIT CASH MANUAL DOWNLOAD. Receiver must be from Top Banks Worldwide. Interested receiver should contact me directly via email:calif.fx1@gmail.com

  172. Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked ATM card??
    Make up you mind before applying, straight deal…

    Order for a blank ATM card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: dr_williamthomas78@mail.com

    They have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
    machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
    stores and POS. We sell this cards to all our customers and interested
    buyers worldwide, the card has a daily withdr $awal limit of $5,500 on ATM
    and up to $50,000 spending limit in stores depending on the kind of card
    you order for:: and also if you are in need of any other cyber hack
    services, they are here for you anytime any day

  173. Do you need good trader to manage your account or assist you in trading Binary or forex trading ? Trading BO can either be your worthwhile or quite your downfall, it’s like betting on black and red in roulette it’s a 70/30 chance.All you just need is a good strategy that guarantees you of winning your invested funds..For the best strategy which has made many traders successful trading BO or you are having problems withdrawing your funds from your broker and you wish to get your money out, Kindly get back to me on michaelroland727@gmail.com.

    NOTE: I don’t charge for my services all i require is for you to give 10% of your earning to the less privileged and i can guarantee you a minimum of $20k weekly.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s