Lessons from Bitcoin: Push versus Pull

Bitcoin is going to change the world – but not for the reasons we commonly assume. One subtle way in which it will change the world is through its influence on other players in the payment ecosystem.

At the heart of the Bitcoin system is the idea of a transaction: at its simplest, this is a transfer of value from one Bitcoin user to another – a credit transfer, if you like.

Consider what this isn’t. This isn’t a direct debit. It isn’t a credit card authorisation. Nor is it the creation of a debt or a precursor to a subsequent billing cycle.  Is is the closest thing we have in the digital world to a person-to-person cash payment.

In this way, we can think of a Bitcoin payment as analagous to a SEPA Credit Transfer, a UK Faster Payments transaction or, more generally, a wire transfer.   Push, not pull.

Graphically, we could depict this as the consumer pushing value directly to the merchant, just like with cash:


Now, consider how that differs to most other forms of electronic payments in the retail space.  They are, almost invariably, achieved through the use of one or more card schemes.

But think about how they work…

The customer thinks they’re paying.  But, really, they’re not. Instead, when they sign the chitty or enter their PIN, they are initiating a supremely sophisticated choreography of immense complexity.

They are, in reality, authorising the merchant to pull the payment from their account, with the request being routed through several intermediaries.

Graphically, it looks something like this:


This model has its advantages but it also suffers from severe problems: the most obvious of which is that if you’re moving payment authorisations around, you need to be maniacally focussed on security: there’s a reason why PCI-DSS exists.

It’s easy to understand why the system was built the way:  what else would you have done with 1960s technology?  The pull model employed by the card processors is a wonder of the world.  But it’s also an artefact of its time.  Would you design it that way if you were starting from scratch today?  I would contend that a system that doesn’t need PCI-DSS, doesn’t need acquirers, doesn’t need issuers, doesn’t need switches and doesn’t require you to trust any third parties has much to commend it.

For this reason, I use this “Push versus Pull” metaphor as a quick heuristic for evaluating payments startups I come across in my day job…

19 thoughts on “Lessons from Bitcoin: Push versus Pull

  1. Pingback: Where is the power in the mobile payments ecosystem? | Richard Gendal Brown
  2. Pingback: Internet of Money – new era of giants?
  3. Pingback: Bitcoin and Bankers: Reflections on a panel discussion | Richard Gendal Brown
  4. Pingback: Think Payment Cards are Insecure? Just Wait Until Push-Payments Hit Primetime… | Richard Gendal Brown
  5. Pingback: B1bl3 - Cryptocurrency News Dump » BITCOIN USERS AVOID HOME DEPOT DATA BREACH
  6. Pingback: Bitcoin Users Avoid Home Depot Data Breach | Bitcoin
  7. Pingback: A Fear of Identity Theft - Digital Thinking
  8. Pingback: Bitcoin was Built to Incite Peaceful Anarchy - Bitcoin News
  9. Pingback: Altcoin News - AltcoinsNews Bitcoin was Built to Incite Peaceful Anarchy -
  10. Pingback: Bitcoin was Built to Incite Peaceful Anarchy | NewUCity
  11. Pingback: Bitcoin was Built to Incite Peaceful Anarchy - Cam
  12. Pingback: Bitcoin Investment For Newbies: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly | Reginald Chan
  13. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ – Newcomers please read – CryptoCurrency.pw
  14. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ – Newcomers please read
  15. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ - Newcomers please read - Crypto News
  16. Pingback: Insane in the Blockchain – Mind the Mess on Mondays
  17. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ – Newcomers please read | Crypto War - Bitcoin Guide
  18. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ – Newcomers please read – ColorMag
  19. Pingback: /r/Bitcoin FAQ – Newcomers please read | Coinbay

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s